Skip to content

Installed byDezire Metal Roofing

Rescrew or Replace a Metal Roof

If the sheet is sound and only the screw washers have perished, new screws can be enough.

Written by
Sydney Metal Roof Replacements
Published
Reading time
6 minutes
A new ridge cap and roof sheeting with the fixings set in line along the crest

Overview

Summarise with AI
ChatGPTClaudeGeminiPerplexity

Opens the assistant with a summary prompt. Gemini does not accept a prompt in the link, so paste it there.

On many ageing metal roofs the steel sheet is still sound while the fixings have failed, because the rubber washer under each screw head perishes decades before the steel around it does. In that specific condition a rescrew, replacing every fixing and washer, is a legitimate option that costs a fraction of a replacement. It is only appropriate where the sheet, valleys and flashings are sound: where the valleys have rusted, a rescrew only lasts a few months and wastes the money. The test is whether the corrosion is at the fixings alone or has reached the sheet and the folded edges.

Key points

  • Washers perish long before the steel does
  • A rescrew replaces every fixing on the roof, not the sheet
  • It is only worth doing if valleys and flashings are sound
  • Rust in the valleys means the roof is at the end of its life
  • Ask before agreeing to a replacement on a roof that is only leaking at screws
01

What a rescrew is

Every sheet on a metal roof is held down by screws, and under each screw head is a rubber or neoprene washer that seals the hole.

That washer is the shortest lived part of the roof. Sun and heat cycling degrade it, and once it has gone hard and cracked, the screw hole is an open path into the roof cavity.

A rescrew removes every fixing on the roof and replaces it with a new screw and washer, usually one gauge larger so it bites fresh timber. The sheet stays where it is.

02

When it is the right answer

The condition it suits is specific, and it is more common than people expect on roofs from the 1980s and 1990s.

Shed roofs are often the best case for it, as shed roof replacement explains.

Rust rings at the screws, clean sheet elsewhere
The typical sign. Staining radiating from each fixing while the pans and ribs between them are sound.
Valleys and flashings still good
These are the parts a rescrew does not touch. If they have gone, the roof needs replacing regardless of the fixings.
Leaks that stop when it is not windy
Water tracking down screw shanks behaves differently from a valley leak, and it often only shows in driving rain.
Battens still holding
A screw needs timber to bite. If the battens have gone soft, new screws will not hold any better than the old ones.
03

When it is a false economy

A rescrew on a roof that is worn out wastes the money, and the test is what the valleys look like.

Valleys carry all the water on a roof and they rust first. Once a valley has gone, the sheet either side of it is the same age, has had the same exposure, and is heading the same way within a few years.

The other disqualifier is the sheet itself. Corrosion along the cut ends, at the ridge, or spreading from dents is the steel failing rather than the fixing, and no amount of new screws addresses it.

Then it is a metal roof replacement, and the money a rescrew would have cost goes towards that instead.

04

Ask about it

If you have been quoted a full replacement for a roof that only leaks at the screws, ask whether a rescrew would do.

The answer may still be that the roof is done, and you will have the reason rather than the conclusion.

It is also a legitimate way to buy time. If a roof is five years from replacement and leaking now, a rescrew can bridge that gap for a fraction of the cost of doing the whole thing early.

05

What it does not do

A rescrew does not extend the life of the sheet, add insulation, fix condensation, or address a flashing that was wrong to begin with.

It also does nothing about the appearance. It will not make an old roof look new.

It fixes one problem, worn screw washers, chosen because that failure mode is the one you have.

If this sounds like your roof

We will come and measure it.

Ring and describe what it is doing, and we will book a time to look at it.

(02) 9072 1993

Common questions

Common questions

How do I know if my roof can be rescrewed?

The short version is whether the valleys are sound. Rust at the fixings with clean valleys and flashings suggests yes, and rust in the valleys suggests the roof is at the end of its life.

Is a rescrew a permanent fix?

It resolves one failure mode. The roof continues ageing, so it buys years rather than resetting the clock.

Will a rescrew stop my leak?

If the leak is water tracking down screw shanks, yes. If it is a valley, a flashing or a penetration, no, and it is worth finding out which before paying for either.

Do you do rescrews?

Ask when you call. We check the screws, the sheet and the valleys, and we will tell you whether a rescrew would do instead of a new roof.

Can I rescrew a roof myself?

It is roof work at height with a fixing pattern and a torque setting that matter. Overtightening crushes the new washer and reproduces the original problem immediately.

Next step

Find out what your roof will cost

We come out, measure your roof and give you a written quote. The quote says what happens if the timber under the old roof turns out to be worse than it looked. Asking for one does not commit you to anything.

Call (02) 9072 1993Get a quote